Skip to main content

Hysteresis

Module 1: Low-Dimensional Dynamics

When a system has an S-shaped bifurcation diagram, the state it occupies depends on the direction in which the parameter changes. This is hysteresis: undoing the change in the parameter does not undo the change in the state (Strogatz 2024, sec. 3.7 and 3.4).

The loop in k

Take \(r = 0.56\) and let \(k\) grow slowly from 5 to 15, then decrease back to 5. “Slowly” means that the population has time to reach the attracting fixed point for each value of \(k\). Figure 1 shows the result on top of the bifurcation diagram from Saddle-Node Bifurcation.

Figure 1: Hysteresis loop of the budworm model for r = 0.56. Increasing k (blue), the population stays on the refuge branch until the fold near k = 9.94 and then jumps to the outbreak branch. Decreasing k (red), it stays on the outbreak branch until the fold near k = 6.45.

The outbreak starts at \(k \approx 9.94\) but only ends when \(k\) drops below \(6.45\). Between these values the answer to “what is the budworm density for this forest?” depends on history.

Run the loop yourself

Here the population is integrated continuously while you change \(k\). The left panel is the bifurcation diagram for the current \(r\) (solid: stable, dashed: unstable), with the path of the state drawn on top. The right panel shows where you are in the \((k, r)\) plane described in the next section.

  1. Press Sweep k up. The state follows the lower stable branch. At which value of \(k\) does it jump? Compare with the dotted fold line: why does the jump come slightly after the fold? (Look at how slowly \(x\) moves just past it.)
  2. When \(k\) reaches 16, press Sweep k down. Where does the outbreak end? The blue and red paths enclose the hysteresis loop.
  3. Reset, drag \(k\) by hand to about 8 and wiggle it between 7 and 9. Does the state ever leave the branch it is on? Repeat after a full sweep up.
  4. Switch the speed to fast and sweep up and down again. Why is the loop wider than the one predicted by the folds?
  5. In the parameter plane, click a point with \(r > 0.65\), above the cusp, and sweep again. What happened to the loop?

Build this in Python. In the lab you sweep the budworm parameters in code and map where the equilibria appear and disappear: Budworm: Integration and Time Series. The optional extension at the end of this page animates the loop with amlab/odes_1d/spruce_budworm_histeresis.py.

The region of bistability

The saddle-node curves from the exercise on the previous page,

\[ r(x) = \frac{2x^3}{(1+x^2)^2}, \qquad k(x) = \frac{2x^3}{x^2 - 1}, \qquad x > 1, \]

bound the region of the \((k, r)\) plane with three positive fixed points (Strogatz 2024, sec. 3.7). The two branches meet at a cusp. Both \(dr/dx\) and \(dk/dx\) vanish at \(x = \sqrt 3\), which gives the cusp point \((k, r) = (3\sqrt 3, 3\sqrt 3/8) \approx (5.20, 0.65)\).

Figure 2: Stability diagram of the budworm model in the (k, r) plane. Inside the shaded region there are two stable fixed points (bistability). The horizontal line r = 0.56 is the path of the loop above.

As \(k \to \infty\) the upper curve approaches \(r = 1/2\). Ludwig et al. used this fact: for a large carrying capacity, outbreaks require \(R > 1/2\) in their notation (Ludwig et al. 1978, 325).

Consequences

  • An outbreak is triggered by crossing one fold and ended only by crossing the other. Returning the parameter to its value just before the outbreak is not enough.
  • Near a fold the refuge state loses resilience: the decay rate \(|f'(x^*)|\) tends to zero, so the system recovers more slowly from perturbations. Similar arguments are used for sudden shifts in lakes, coral reefs and forests (Scheffer et al. 2001).
NoteExercise

Fix \(k = 10\) and vary \(r\) instead. The folds are at \(r \approx 0.384\) and \(r \approx 0.560\). Describe what happens when \(r\) increases from 0.3 to 0.7 and then decreases back to 0.3.

Starting on the refuge branch, the population stays low until \(r \approx 0.560\), where the refuge fixed point disappears and the population jumps to the outbreak level. On the way back it stays high until \(r \approx 0.384\), where the outbreak fixed point disappears and it drops to the refuge. Between 0.384 and 0.560 the state depends on the direction of change.

TipOptional extension

amlab/odes_1d/spruce_budworm_histeresis.py lets \(k\) oscillate in time, \(k(t) = k_0 + A(1 + \sin 2\pi f t)\), and animates \(x\) against \(k\). Run it locally:

from amlab.odes_1d.spruce_budworm_histeresis import make_animation

make_animation()

Change r inside make_animation to 0.56 and k0, amp so that \(k\) spans the interval \([6, 11]\). Does a loop appear? What happens if you increase the frequency freq?

References

Ludwig, D., D. D. Jones, and C. S. Holling. 1978. “Qualitative Analysis of Insect Outbreak Systems: The Spruce Budworm and Forest.” Journal of Animal Ecology 47 (1): 315–32. https://doi.org/10.2307/3939.
Scheffer, Marten, Steve Carpenter, Jonathan A. Foley, Carl Folke, and Brian Walker. 2001. “Catastrophic Shifts in Ecosystems.” Nature 413 (6856): 591–96. https://doi.org/10.1038/35098000.
Strogatz, Steven H. 2024. Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos: With Applications to Physics, Biology, Chemistry, and Engineering. Chapman; Hall/CRC.